(And Why Chasing Them Makes It Worse)
By Shelly Haines, Fetch Worthy Dog Training
Who this is for: This post is written for owners of young puppies, roughly 8 to 16 weeks old, during the key socialization window and before vaccines are complete. If your dog is older or already showing serious guarding, reach out for one-on-one help.
In my puppy program, this is the number one issue I talk to owners about, and I bring it up right away. I see it all the time.
I also get calls from people I’ve never worked with. Their dogs are around a year old and swallow everything they can find. It’s a huge problem. Sometimes it’s already meant a trip to the emergency vet. When I ask, “Were you taking things out of your puppy’s mouth?” the answer is almost always the same: “Yes, because I didn’t want my puppy to get sick.”
Those owners did what they thought was right. But all that grabbing taught their puppy to swallow first and ask questions later. That’s exactly what I want to help you avoid.
Sticks, leaves, mulch, rocks, wrappers, and, yes, poop. If your puppy is vacuuming up everything on your walks, you’re not alone. It’s one of the most common worries we hear from new puppy owners. And it’s no wonder: social media is full of scary emergency-room stories, and many owners are told to keep their puppy inside or never let them pick anything up.
Here’s the truth: exploring with their mouth is normal puppy behavior. How you respond matters far more than the stick itself. Handle it the wrong way, and you can accidentally create a puppy who runs away, swallows things fast, or guards what they have. Handle it right, and you raise a dog who happily gives things up.
Why Puppies Pick Everything Up
Puppies learn about the world through their nose and mouth, just like human babies grab and taste everything. Sniffing, tasting, and carrying things around helps them figure out what’s safe, what’s food, and what’s fun. Teething adds to the urge to chew.
In other words, your puppy isn’t being bad. They’re being a puppy.
How Chasing and Grabbing Create Resource Guarding
What Is Resource Guarding?
Resource guarding is when a dog tries to keep something they value away from people or other animals. Many owners picture growling or biting, but guarding often starts subtly. It can look like:
- Swallowing an object fast before you can take it. This can turn into an emergency vet visit.
- Running away from you when they have something.
- Hovering over an item, a toy, or their food bowl.
- Putting a paw on it and refusing to give it up.
- Freezing or going stiff, eating faster, or turning their head away when you come close.
- Growling, snapping, or biting are more serious signs.
The mild signs matter. They’re your puppy telling you they’re worried about losing something. Your response decides whether it fades or grows.
When a puppy picks something up, most of us instinctively chase them down and pull it out of their mouth. Unfortunately, every time that happens, your puppy learns:
- This must be valuable. If you want it that badly, it’s worth keeping.
- Hands near my mouth mean I lose things. Your puppy starts to avoid your approach.
- Next time, run, gulp, or guard. Swallowing fast or growling is how puppies protect what they think they’ll lose.
Imagine someone snatching your phone or your coffee out of your hand every time you picked it up. You’d hold on tighter and hide things, too. That’s how resource guarding starts, and it’s how puppies end up swallowing the very things we were trying to keep them from.
Not Everything Is an Emergency
It helps to know what actually matters:
- Dangerous: trade for it right away. Socks, medications, corn cobs, cooked bones, batteries, grapes, xylitol gum, and poop from unknown dogs. Be careful not to backchain the sock grab! If you’re doing this more than once a day, you are NOT on a good track. Puppy-proof.
- Low concern: let it go or call your puppy away. Leaves, grass, paper, bugs, and small twigs.
- Most dogs know: instinctively know what is poisonous and won’t eat things that taste bad or aren’t edible. Some dogs with undiagnosed medical conditions may eat rocks and have GI issues that can make them eat objects.
If your puppy swallows something dangerous, call your vet.
Common Texas Plants That Are Toxic to Dogs
- Sago palm: extremely toxic, especially the seeds. Even one or two can cause liver failure.
- Oleander: every part is poisonous and can cause heart problems.
- Lantana, including native Texas lantana: unripe berries can cause liver damage.
- Castor bean: the seeds contain ricin, which can be deadly.
- Chinaberry tree (also called Texas umbrella tree): toxic to dogs.
- Mistletoe: quite toxic and can affect the nervous system.
- Poinsettia: mostly an irritant that causes stomach upset, not as dangerous as its reputation.
For the full list, see the ASPCA’s toxic and non-toxic plant list for dogs and Texas A&M AgriLife’s Plant Toxicity and Pets. If you think your puppy ate something toxic, call your vet or the ASPCA Animal Poison Control Center at (888) 426-4435.
What to Do Instead
1. Puppy-proof everything, then puppy-proof again. This is the number one, easiest way to prevent this problem. If your puppy can’t get to it, you never have to take it away. Once your puppy picks up something they shouldn’t have, they should never see it again. Put it away for good so it’s never available. Keep floors clear, walk the yard before outings, and use a long line so you can guide instead of chase.
2. Teach “Drop It” before you need it. I teach a classically conditioned “Drop It” from trainer Chirag Patel: say “Drop it,” then toss a few treats on the floor. Do this over and over every day. Practice this daily before any object is involve. These words always mean something great is coming.
3. Teach a hand target (“Touch”). Teaching your puppy to bump their nose to your hand gives you an easy way to call them away from things without a chase. Do this all day, about 15 times a day!
4. Get your puppy to chase you. If your puppy grabs something and starts to run, don’t follow. Turn and jog away happily, ask for a “Touch” when they catch up, and then scatter treats a little to the side. While they eat, calmly pick up the object.
5. Try the “I Found a Treasure” game. Get down on the floor and act like you’ve discovered something amazing: “Oh my gosh, what’s this?” Most puppies will drop what they have to come see. Then reward with a big treat scatter.
6. Give them a “yes” outlet. Snuffle mats, scatter feeding, and safe exploration in a controlled area satisfy your puppy’s natural need to forage. Novel-object foraging is important for safe exploration.
What About Parvo and Going Outside?
How parvo spreads: Parvo spreads through contact with infected dog feces or anything contaminated by it, like soil, shoes, and toys (NIH). Infected dogs shed huge amounts of the virus in their poop. It can survive in the environment for months. Puppies pick it up by sniffing or licking contaminated ground, not from leaves or sticks in a clean yard.
Parvo is a real risk for young puppies. Vets are right to take it seriously. But research shows that puppies who have had at least one vaccine and attend well-run socialization classes are no more at risk of parvo than puppies who stay home. The American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior recommends starting socialization before vaccines are complete.
Choose the right places: your yard, a vaccinated friend’s home, and clean puppy classes are great. Dog parks, pet stores, and busy shared potty areas can wait. A puppy stroller is a fantastic way to let your puppy see the world without walking on high-risk ground. Read more here for helpful tips.
Real Puppies, Real Results
With every puppy client, the very first thing I teach is “Drop It.” Here are two of my favorite turnarounds.
The golden retriever who picked up everything. This puppy wanted every single thing he could find, and his mom was chasing him down to get it back. We worked on “Drop It,” saying “Bring It,” walking away, and playing the chase-me game. It worked like magic.
The Portuguese water dog who loved socks. Socks were his favorite prize, and the whole family was chasing him to get them back. I convinced everyone to stop chasing and to manage the house: no socks left anywhere, ever. It was like magic. The puppy stopped. Then we taught him to retrieve. Now he brings things or loses interest instead of running off with them.

The Bottom Line
Your puppy picking things up is normal. Chasing and grabbing teaches guarding. Management, a strong “Drop It,” and a puppy who loves coming to you will keep them safe and raise a confident dog that gives things up freely.
Want help with your puppy? Fetch Worthy Dog Training offers puppy training programsin Austin, Buda, and the Kyle area. Built on safe socialization and positive reinforcement. Visit fetchworthy.net to get started.

Contact Us
Fetch Worthy Dog Training by Shelly Haines, VSA-CDT, FFCP, offers private dog training & virtual puppy training!